Full Xbox Games On Live: CONFIRMED

> News Comments > SPOnG Comments Index

Topic started: Wed, 14 Nov 2007 10:19
Click here to view the news article this topic refers to.
Page:«12
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 10:19
According to what MCV have on their site only those that had Xbox Live on the original Xbox since its 'infancy' will get 500points.

It might be an idea to perhaps clarify this with Microsoft.
king skins
Joined 10 Mar 2005
563 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 12:45
Eurogamer are reporting the same thing, you'll get 500 points if you've been a member since 2002... which is a ass if true, I think I joined in early 2003 :(
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 13:10
Oh and again the title is misleading saying 'Free Live games tomorrow!'

Its 1 game and let me guess...Your including the fact that you're getting 500points isn't it Spong? But then again seems to only apply to old Live members.
TimSpong
Joined 6 Nov 2006
1783 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 13:25
SuperSaiyan4 wrote:
According to what MCV have on their site only those that had Xbox Live on the original Xbox since its 'infancy' will get 500points..


Yup - that was abysmally overlooked in the finished story. Amended and updated now.

Cheers

Tim
TimSpong
Joined 6 Nov 2006
1783 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 13:33
SuperSaiyan4 wrote:
Oh and again the title is misleading saying 'Free Live games tomorrow!'

Its 1 game and let me guess...Your including the fact that you're getting 500points isn't it Spong? But then again seems to only apply to old Live members.


Nah, that won't fly - and was made clear in the copy... what we have been told is, "all eight-million members will have the opportunity to download a free Xbox LIVE Arcade game".

That doesn't mean "a free XBLA Arcade game from a choice of one".

Tim
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 13:41
Tim, from what I have read on other sites its only 1 free Live game called Carcassonne.

So now Microsoft are saying for launch members only?? Well I find that very unfair considering I started just 6months after launch! Oh well hope this isn't true!
TimSpong
Joined 6 Nov 2006
1783 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 13:55
SuperSaiyan4 wrote:
Tim, from what I have read on other sites its only 1 free Live game called Carcassonne.

So now Microsoft are saying for launch members only?? Well I find that very unfair considering I started just 6months after launch! Oh well hope this isn't true!


We're still waiting for Microsoft to confirm this with us. In the event that it is just for foundation members then I'd agree it smacks of unfair.

On the other hand - if you were a foundation member, and someone who'd join three minutes ago got the same benefits as you, then you'd be p.o'd... which is why the additional points really should have gone to founder members, while the free game(s) should have gone to all. That's all IMHO, however.

Cheers - as ever -

Tim
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 14:04
Tim Smith wrote:
SuperSaiyan4 wrote:
Tim, from what I have read on other sites its only 1 free Live game called Carcassonne.

So now Microsoft are saying for launch members only?? Well I find that very unfair considering I started just 6months after launch! Oh well hope this isn't true!


We're still waiting for Microsoft to confirm this with us. In the event that it is just for foundation members then I'd agree it smacks of unfair.

On the other hand - if you were a foundation member, and someone who'd join three minutes ago got the same benefits as you, then you'd be p.o'd... which is why the additional points really should have gone to founder members, while the free game(s) should have gone to all. That's all IMHO, however.

Cheers - as ever -

Tim


Actually it doesn't bother me if everyone gets 500points for free I think that would be very nice for Microsoft to do that.

Its only when some companies only offer NEW customers better deals than existing customers thats when many get upset.

In this case if someone signs up to Live today and gets free points but everyone else that signed up gets it anyways then nothing to complain about.

But when Microsoft offer 5 free HD-DVD's to new buyers of the add-on but not to existing customers thats when I get upset and say its not fair.
TimSpong
Joined 6 Nov 2006
1783 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 14:08
Tim Smith wrote:
We're still waiting for Microsoft to confirm this with us. In the event that it is just for foundation members then I'd agree it smacks of unfair.


Quoting myself = urgh... anyway, to clarify - we are getting confirmation from Microsoft regarding EUROPE and Carcassonne. Because the way this news has come to Europe leaves ambiguity (and the fact that US time zones were used doesn't help) galore.

Cheers for the prodding - I'd prefer our readers to keep us on our toes rather than if they simply don't say anything when we aren't right on the Mark.

Regards

Tim
RiseFromYourGrave
Joined 17 Jul 2006
687 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 15:42
so Tim is the game this Carcassonne, which is hexic 2 i understand? might use that mandatory free month of gold if it isnt just that one ame and i have some choice
TimSpong
Joined 6 Nov 2006
1783 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 15:50
RiseFromYourGrave wrote:
so Tim is the game this Carcassonne, which is hexic 2 i understand? might use that mandatory free month of gold if it isnt just that one ame and i have some choice


Right now, Rise... the European info from Microsoft does not mention a game by the name.

The US information is that the game is Carcassonne.

Confusing... so our Mark SPOnG is currently chasing Microsoft (Europe) for the definitive information.

Cheers

Tim
Spinface
Joined 19 Jul 2006
211 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 15:56
RiseFromYourGrave wrote:
so Tim is the game this Carcassonne, which is hexic 2 i understand? might use that mandatory free month of gold if it isnt just that one ame and i have some choice


Yeah, I'm chasing this. The announcement Microsoft sent out over here mentioned no specific game, the U.S. site says different. Bloody confusing.
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 16:21
Spinface wrote:
RiseFromYourGrave wrote:
so Tim is the game this Carcassonne, which is hexic 2 i understand? might use that mandatory free month of gold if it isnt just that one ame and i have some choice


Yeah, I'm chasing this. The announcement Microsoft sent out over here mentioned no specific game, the U.S. site says different. Bloody confusing.


Just want to say Carcassonne and Hexic 2 are 2 different games.

I got a funny feeling this offer doesn't apply to Europe as there is no info on xbox.com/uk

Oh well guess its time to sign into my USA account to nab the free arcade game! muahahaha wonder if its any good.
RiseFromYourGrave
Joined 17 Jul 2006
687 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 16:47

ah, theyre one and the same in korea, according to joystiq.

http://www.joystiq.com/2007/11/13/ms-confirms-downloadable-xbox-games-free-carcassonne-for-live-a/

not really into board games. if i had the option of some more genres id be all over this though
SuperSaiyan4
Joined 15 Aug 2006
1274 comments
Wed, 14 Nov 2007 16:52
RiseFromYourGrave wrote:

ah, theyre one and the same in korea, according to joystiq.

http://www.joystiq.com/2007/11/13/ms-confirms-downloadable-xbox-games-free-carcassonne-for-live-a/

not really into board games. if i had the option of some more genres id be all over this though


Well Hexic 2 is not a board game...So it cannot be the same as carcassonne...

carcassonne and Hexic 2 are 2 different arcade games looks like joystick are wrong...very wrong.
<< Prev12

Log-in or register to permanently change your layout setting.